Inclusive line management: recruitment

Part two of our blog series.
A lesser-known piece of work spearheaded by the Julian Teaching School Hub is our Workforce Development Forum. An outgrowth of our steering group, the forum meets termly; attendance has widened from just steering group members to HR representatives from various MATs and the Local Authority. Powered by remarkable candour and professional generosity, discussions have focused on people development, talent mapping, and line management.
As an offshoot of this work, Cat Randall-Smith (Head of HR, St John the Baptist Catholic MAT) and Susi Waters (Norfolk Research School, the Julian Teaching School Hub) have collaborated on a piece of work that we are delighted to present as a short blog series: Inclusive line management. This series will cover recruitment, CPD and development, belonging and wellbeing, and flexible working. We hope you find it useful.
2. Inclusive recruitment
Pupils notice who teaches them, who leads the school and who does which jobs. This shapes what they think is possible for people like them. There's good evidence that it matters:
- In one long-running US study, Black pupils who had at least one Black teacher in their first few years of school were more likely to finish school and go on to college.
- Closer to home, only 16 per cent of secondary pupils in Edurio's pupil survey said they often learn about people like themselves.
It matters to staff too. Being the only person like you in the staffroom is isolating, and people apply for jobs where they can picture themselves fitting in. The message we should want every applicant to get from us is this: you'll be welcome here, you won't be the only one, and you can grow here.
We could start by thinking about whether the way we recruit quietly filters people out before we ever meet them, beginning with the advert:
- If we say flexible working is welcome, we should mean it. A lot of good people might not apply because they assume that when they ask, the answer will be no.
- Look hard at your essential criteria. If you wouldn't turn down a strong candidate without it, it's desirable rather than essential. Long lists of essentials put off the people who only apply when they tick every box.
- Following on from this, we could say it in the advert: if you meet most of the criteria, please still apply. Interestingly, LinkedIn found that women apply for 20 per cent fewer jobs than men but are 16 per cent more likely to be hired when they do. The problem isn’t that they’re not good enough; they’re ruling themselves out before they apply. That’s worth thinking about, especially for roles where women are under-represented.
- Be open about adjustments and accommodations for the interview day. Rather than "adjustments available on request", give a few examples, such as questions in advance, a quiet room or a step-free interview room
- Be explicit about embracing diversity. We could say that a team with a range of backgrounds and perspectives is a stronger team, and that we'd like our staff to reflect the communities we serve.
- Use plain English and avoid acronyms.
- Advertise beyond the usual places. Parents, the parish and community groups often reach people the job boards don't.
Think about the person as much as their experience. For TAs, for example, someone warm, reliable and good with children can learn school systems and processes. Insisting on school experience for an office or site role narrows the pool to people who already work in schools.
Write down the qualities you're looking for before you meet anyone, and ask everyone the same questions. Otherwise, "the right sort of person" turns into "someone like us."
Get creative with the questions you ask. Asking someone to explain something to you that they’re interested in that you may know nothing about is a great way to see someone’s personality come to life, and it lets them know that you’re interested in them as a person, not just as someone to fulfil a role.
The biases that show up most in recruitment are:
- Warming to people who remind us of ourselves.
- Letting one first impression colour everything else.
- Making assumptions about commitment, whether that's about parents, carers, part-timers or older candidates.
Question: With an equivalent CV, how many more applications did people with minority ethnic names have to send to get a positive reply?
Answer: 60% more applications.
So what helps?
Agree what good looks like before anyone reads an application. Remove names and personal details before shortlisting. Shortlist with two people and note your reasons. Ask everyone the same core questions. And have each panel member score on their own before you discuss, otherwise the most senior person in the room tends to set the answer.
When someone says a candidate is a good fit, it's worth asking: fit with what? In a 2024 survey of neurodivergent adults, more than a quarter of those who disclosed their neurodivergence had been turned down for roles, with subjective reasons like "communication style" or "team fit" cited. A better question to ask is what might this person add?
An interview day that works for everyone
An inclusive, accessible process lets you see the candidate, not just how well they cope in an interview.
For everyone:
- Tell candidates what the day involves, and ask each of them, "Is there anything we can do to make the day work well for you?"
- Consider offering time with the questions beforehand.
- Avoid multipart or run-on questions.
- Have the questions written down for candidates to refer to while answering.
- Avoid group tasks where you can.
For physical access, think about the building and the tour. Is the room step-free? Is the tour a long walk with stairs?
For race, faith and background, check everyone's right to work in exactly the same way. Treat experience abroad as valuable professional experience, not a problem to be concerned about. Judge how clearly someone communicates, not their accent. Avoid major religious festivals and Friday prayers where you can.
Finally, recruitment doesn't end with the offer. The first few weeks in a role decide whether people stay:
- Get in touch before day one.
- Provide a buddy who isn't their line manager.
- Explain the unwritten rules, like morning briefing, the staffroom and who covers what.
- Check in at two weeks and six weeks, and give support staff the same welcome as teachers.
The third part of this series will focus on CPD and development.